What is a social media audit – and why is it essential?

A social media audit is a systematic inventory of all your social media presences. You analyze profile completeness, content performance, engagement patterns, KPI development and the position of your competitors. The result: a clear picture of the current situation and a prioritized list of measures.

The difference between a good and a bad social media presence rarely lies in the budget – it lies in the regularity of the analysis. Companies that audit on a quarterly basis optimize faster, save advertising budget in the long term and react to platform changes at an early stage.

How you proceed depends on the size of your company. For initial orientation, we recommend taking a look at our agency services, which show which depth of analysis makes sense for which type of company.

Step 1 – Inventory and check all channels

Before you analyze anything, you need a complete list of all social media profiles associated with your company – including inactive, forgotten or former employee accounts. Simply use the search function on Instagram, LinkedIn, TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Pinterest and X – with company names, product names and name variants.

You record the following basic data in a table for each channel:

• Platform and profile URL
• User name / Handle
• Current number of followers
• Last post (date)
• Responsible person or team
• Link to corporate objectives (yes/no)

Profiles that have been inactive for more than six months and have no strategic function should be deactivated or consolidated. Every channel you actively use costs resources – and a half-hearted presence is worse than none.

Step 2 – Check profile completeness on all channels

Many companies underestimate the influence of a fully completed profile on organic reach and conversion. Platforms such as LinkedIn and Instagram prioritize complete profiles algorithmically. Here is the audit checklist for the profile level:

Step 3 – Systematically evaluate content performance

Content analysis is at the heart of every audit. This is where you decide which formats and topics to scale – and what to adjust. For each active channel, go back at least 90 days and export the performance data from the respective native analytics tool (Meta Business Suite, LinkedIn Analytics, TikTok Analytics, etc.).

Sort all posts by reach, engagement rate and saves/shares. These three metrics show different things:

• Reach shows how much the algorithm distributes your content
• Engagement rate shows how relevant the content is for your target group
• Saves/shares show real added value – these are the most valuable interactions

Identify the top 10 posts and the flop 10 posts. Search for patterns: Which formats, topics, posting times or image styles perform better? The analysis often shows clear clusters – for example, that carousel posts with specific tips generate three times as many saves as pure brand posts.

Agency tip: Don’t just evaluate absolute figures, but always the engagement rate (interactions divided by reach). A post with 200 likes at 500 reach is more valuable than one with 200 likes at 50,000 reach. Only the engagement rate shows you whether your content is really relevant – and not just seen by many people by chance.

For an in-depth look at the right metrics, it’s worth reading our article on social media KPIs for companies – where we explain which metrics are really relevant for decision-making and which you can ignore.

Step 4 – Evaluate KPIs and recalibrate targets

An audit without a target comparison is worthless. In the fourth step, you compare each measured KPI with a target value. If you have not yet defined any target values, now is the right time – derived from industry benchmarks and your own previous quarter’s data.

Typical benchmark values for B2B companies in Germany:

• LinkedIn engagement rate: 2-4 % good, over 5 % very good
• Instagram engagement rate: 1-3 % good, over 4 % very good
• TikTok completion rate: over 50 % is the target
• Follower growth: 3-8 % per month as a healthy guideline
• Social-to-website traffic: 5-15% of total traffic for B2B

Every deviation between actual and target is a field of action. Prioritize by impact: Which improvement will have the greatest effect on your business goals? Building on clean reporting for managers helps enormously – find out more in our guide to social media reporting for managers.

Step 5 – Competitive analysis as a strategy anchor

No audit is complete without a look at the competition. It’s not about copying – it’s about finding gaps that you can fill and understanding strengths that you need to differentiate yourself against.

Analyze the following points for 3-5 direct competitors:

• Which channels are actively used?
• How high are follower numbers and growth?
• Which content formats dominate?
• Which topics and keywords does the competitor focus on?
• How is the community interaction (do they respond, do the followers praise, is there criticism)?

Tools such as SimilarWeb, Sprout Social or native platform insights can help with this. You can find a complete overview of the best tools and methods in our article on social media competition analysis for companies.

The result of the competitive analysis should always be a clear answer to this question: What do we do differently and better than the others – and how do we communicate this on our channels?

Step 6 – Transfer audit results into an action plan

The last step is the most important – and the one where most companies fail. An audit without a concrete action plan is a wasted analysis. Structure your measures into three categories:

• Quick wins (can be implemented immediately): Profile optimizations, retrofit UTM tagging, improve response time, deactivate inactive profiles
• Medium-term (4-8 weeks): Adapt content strategy, revise editorial plan, test new formats
• Strategic (quarter): Reprioritize channel strategy, adjust budget allocation, evaluate new platforms

Every measure needs a responsible person, a date and a success criterion. Only then will the audit become an actual improvement – and not a checklist.

If you are unsure whether your internal team can fully implement the audit, it is worth looking for external support. You can find more information on this under Contact us.

Frequently asked questions about the social media audit

More on the topic: Social media monitoring – competition analysis – calculate ROI – plan your budget

Related articles

• Social media agency – services and expertise
• Social media KPIs: What really counts
• Social media competition analysis: tools and methods
• Social media reporting for managers
• Contact – Request a social media audit

Why competitive analysis on social media is indispensable

Without comparative values, you don’t know whether your engagement rate is good or can be improved. Only when you see that your competitor with a similar audience achieves twice as many comments will you recognize a concrete need for action. Competitor analysis is not a one-off project, but an ongoing process: platforms change their algorithms, new formats emerge and competitors adjust their strategy.

Step 1: Identify the right competitors

Before you start the analysis, you need a clear list of your relevant competitors. Direct competitors offer the same product or service. Indirect competitors solve the same problem in a different way. And then there are the so-called aspirational brands – companies that you don’t compete with directly, but whose social media presence is so strong that it serves as a benchmark.

Start with a list of five to ten direct competitors. For each one, check which platforms they are active on, how often they post and how large their community is. A company that has 200,000 followers on TikTok but hardly any presence on LinkedIn has a completely different strategy than a competitor that consistently uses LinkedIn and Xing for B2B contacts.

Step 2: Define and measure key figures

Without clear KPIs, the analysis remains vague. The following key figures are particularly meaningful for competitive analysis:

• Follower growth: How quickly is the competitor expanding its community?
• Engagement rate: Interactions (likes, comments, shares) divided by reach or followers
• Post frequency: How often do you post per week – on which platforms?
• Content mix: ratio of video, image, carousel, story and link posts
• Response time: How quickly does the competitor respond to comments and messages?
• Share of Voice: How big is the share of relevant mentions compared to you?

This data can be collected automatically with the right tools. Manual tracking in a spreadsheet is enough to get you started, but quickly becomes confusing as soon as you monitor more than three competitors.

Agency tip: Analyze not only what competitors are posting, but also what they are not posting. Topics that are relevant in your industry but are avoided by the competition are often the best content opportunities for your own strategy.

The 5 best tools for social media competition analysis

Depending on your budget and analysis goal, there are different tools that can help you to systematically monitor your competitors. The following table provides an overview of the five most frequently used tools:

For smaller companies with a limited budget, a hybrid approach is recommended: SimilarWeb in the free version for traffic data, combined with the native analysis tools of the platforms (Meta Business Suite, TikTok Analytics, LinkedIn Campaign Manager). For professional agency analysis, there is no way around a specialized tool such as Rival IQ or Sprout Social.

Step 3: Decipher the competition’s content strategy

Once you have collected the key figures, it’s time for the qualitative analysis: What does your competitor’s content say about their positioning and target group? Pay attention to the following aspects:

Themes and messages

Which core topics does the competitor cover? Is there a clear narrative (e.g. sustainability, innovation, community) or does the feed seem randomly put together? Brands with a consistent thematic framework generally achieve significantly higher engagement rates because fans know exactly what they are following.

Format mix and posting times

Analyze whether video posts achieve more reach than static images, whether stories or reels perform better and whether there are certain days of the week and times of day when the competition has an above-average number of interactions. This data provides you with direct recommendations for your own editorial planning.

Sound and community interaction

How does the competitor address his followers – formally or on a first-name basis, humorously or objectively? How do they deal with critical comments? A brand that responds quickly and empathetically to negative reviews builds more trust in the long term than one that ignores or deletes criticism.

Step 4: Derive ROI-relevant findings

The competitive analysis is only valuable if it leads to concrete measures. Translate your findings into action: If your competitor consistently achieves over 5% engagement rates with short explainer videos on Instagram Reels, but you hardly produce any video content yourself, that’s a clear signal. If a competitor uses certain hashtags or trending sounds that are relevant to your target group but are not yet being used by you, this is an opportunity that can be realized quickly.

Link the results to your social media strategy and calculate what measurable impact the planned measures should have on your ROI. Only those who define goals can measure the success of their analyses. Find out more in our guide to calculating ROI for social media.

Step 5: Regular analysis and reporting

A one-off competitive analysis is a good starting point, but not a permanent solution. Social media platforms are evolving rapidly: new formats (such as TikTok Shopsor Instagram Broadcast Channels) are changing the rules of the game and competitors are constantly adapting their strategy. Therefore, set up a regular analysis rhythm:

1. Monthly: Key figure check (follower development, engagement, post frequency)
2. Quarterly: In-depth content analysis (topics, formats, cooperations)
3. Annual: Strategy review including new competitors and platform trends

Automate as much as possible: Set up automated reports in your tool that are sent to the team on a weekly or monthly basis. This way, analysis remains an integral part of your workflow without taking up a disproportionate amount of time. If you have any questions about your individual analysis strategy, our social media agency will be happy to help – just get in touch with us via the contact page.

More on the topic: Social media monitoring – Audit checklist – Brand awareness – Calculate ROI